myCFO: Corruption in Financial Services: Inevitable?

myCFO logo

myCFO logo


[from 2007] Some great dirt in yesterday’s WSJ about a company I used to be associated with, myCFO, which was founded during the dotcom bubble to service the financial needs of the booming numbers of IPO-based multimillionaires here in Silicon Valley.

There was nothing wrong with the basic idea: instead of allowing the investment banking and white-shoe firms like Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley that took their companies public to grab the followon business of investing their fortunes, these folks would set up a technology-oriented, unbiased practice which would function as a family office for the them.

I had been functioning as a family office for one such IPO multimillionaire for several years when the straight-arrow accountant we used, Kevin McAuliffe at Ernst&Young, became a founding director at myCFO. It appeared they were going to build an excellent management platform which would relieve me of the tedious backoffice business of keeping detailed portfolio records in my expensive portfolio management system (Axys) and generate all the necessary custom reports for me, so I brought my clients over to myCFO, which was making all the right noises. Technically I was a client of theirs and so paid them for certain services — as were my clients. But in practice, we were supposed to be partners in serving my clients.

At first all seemed to go well, and all my records were successfully transferred to myCFO’s Axys-based (temporarily, they said) accounting system. But very little happened in rolling out the web-based management platform, and after a year of promises without results I started to get annoyed. Then myCFO began to interfere with the relationship with my clients, pushing on them investment packages I deemed unwise and trying to go around me to persuade them to do things. This was not the way the relationship was supposed to work, and it was clear that despite their claim to be neutral presenters of investment products, the same incentives to market packages for high fees were starting to make themselves felt. I started to have to spend time inoculating my clients against these marketing pressures. Eventually the strain of this contributed to my deciding to close up shop and retire, since I no longer needed the money. My other reasonable alternative was to restructure myself into a hedge fund, but I didn’t really feel the motivation to undertake another startup-equivalent effort.

Here’s an excerpt from an email I wrote to the new investment services manager there as the company began to fall apart in late 2002:

I have been preoccupied with end-of-year tax strategizing and portfolio cleanup. The personal portfolio’s first stage was done two weeks ago, second stage (required by wash-sale rules) scheduled for Dec. 10th or so. The result is about $400K captured losses for future use, plus a more manageable portfolio.

The CRT part of the process was thrown into some turmoil because I was given bad information about the taxation of CRT gains and losses, and never received a copy of the CRT’s current tax account status as requested in mid-year. Capturing tax losses (beyond what’s needed to cover any short-term gains) in the CRT is useful only to a small extent which only appears under some scenarios, so there is no need to swap one position for another just for that reason; the reason to consolidate is more for sake of management ease. The earlier work done on this has to be redone with these new considerations, so wholesale exchanges are probably not worth the cost. I would suggest that people in meetings refrain from making off-the-top-of-their-head strategy pronouncements about tax-complex entities in future.

I don’t know what’s going to be left of myCFO under the new dispensation, though I will be happy to advise **** and **** on service choices. In my view the company totally failed in its original premise, which was application of web technology to remove all the “sticky” factors which made service of wealthy family needs difficult. It was my unwise idea to take a chance on myCFO, and I take responsibility for the inconvenience to [my clients]. At least it’s clear that they did not suffer financially, but it is far from clear that myCFO’s advisory practice is the best choice going forward, and I suggest [my clients] treat as a sales effort any meeting such as you describe where I am not there to note distortions and unproved assertions. And in this field, distortions and unproved assertions are standard practice. myCFO is not the same organization now, and it remains to be seen whether it has conflicts of interest in advisory services similar to standard brokerages now that it is controlled by the Bank of Montreal. It is widely expected that the bank purchased myCFO for the profits to be had in asset management, and if so the activities of IAS in future should be viewed with great suspicion. Goodwill once sold has a way of being milked.

Well, it turns out that myCFO fell for the temptation to sell bad tax shelters to its less scrupulous clients. The straight-arrow tax guy I worked with, Kevin McAuliffe, has a 120-page deposition he gave about the topic posted at the WSJ website yesterday. It makes for interesting reading – no matter how much he tried to warn others that these fee-heavy shelters were bad news for both clients and the company, he was ignored as the firm rushed to beef up its revenues for the expected IPO. Kevin left shortly before I did as the bad actors drove out the good.

[Ed. note: the story link has rotted, so I include the text below.] John Doerr, Silicon Valley VC legend, comes off looking like an ass.

HOUSE OF ‘CARDS’

Fling With Tax Shelters Haunts Silicon Valley
Funded by Tech Barons, MyCFO Inc. Sold Deal The IRS Later Nullified
By PETER WALDMAN
March 6, 2007; Page A1

John Doerr is the dean of Silicon Valley venture capitalists, one who helped launch tech icons like Google and Sun Microsystems. A billionaire, he works with rock star Bono to fight poverty in Africa and with others to increase aid for education and medical research.

Mr. Doerr is less well known for one investment that didn’t pan out. Called myCFO Inc., the firm set out to provide rich people a full menu of financial services, from wealth management to estate planning. It succeeded with only one: tax shelters that helped clients shield hundreds of millions of dollars from taxes. Less than two years after myCFO began selling them in 2000, the Internal Revenue Service said they were bogus.

MyCFO ceased independent operations five years ago, but it still casts a shadow. A bank that underwrote some of its tax deals has admitted that they were shams. Former clients, hit with back-tax bills, are fighting the IRS. Two ex-clients have alleged that myCFO’s tax deals were fraudulent.

Two lawyers who worked with myCFO are under tax-fraud indictment for their work on similar tax shelters. The Manhattan U.S. attorney’s office, which has charged more than a dozen people in connection with tax shelters, said in a court filing last April that it had “an ongoing criminal investigation” involving “various former employees of myCFO.”

The financial backers and board members of myCFO were Silicon Valley royalty. They included James H. Clark, co-founder of Netscape Communications and Silicon Graphics; John Chambers of Cisco Systems Inc.; Thomas Jermoluk, former chairman of Excite@Home; and former Netscape boss James Barksdale. The firm’s outside legal counsel was Larry Sonsini, lawyer to Silicon Valley’s stars.

The firm was Mr. Clark’s idea. Mr. Doerr led its financing and took a leading role on the board. In typical Silicon Valley fashion, board members were closely involved with strategy and operations, according to company documents and legal papers reviewed by The Wall Street Journal. The documents show that directors pushed ahead with the tax-shelter business despite signs that all wasn’t right with the product.

Mr. Doerr praised the head of the firm’s tax-strategies group in a 2001 email for “not only delivering on your original [business] plan, but going beyond to make up the revenue shortfall from the recurring business.” MyCFO “has my full support, and the full support of [my] partners” at Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, the venture-capital firm that financed myCFO, he added.

MyCFO’s story shows how the sudden wealth spawned by the technology boom had hidden impacts that still echo in Silicon Valley. “There were 30-year-old clients making hundreds of millions of dollars — it was intoxicating,” says James Phillips, myCFO’s former chief investment officer. “The accountants and CPAs wanted their share, too.”

At the time, tax shelters were a lively business. Dozens of national law and accounting firms sold these strategies — Byzantine transactions that often involved foreign currencies and offshore middlemen. MyCFO selected a few tax shelters and refined them for a clientele dripping in capital gains.

Some of California’s leading industrialists were customers. Ray Irani, chief executive of Occidental Petroleum Corp., did a tax deal through myCFO, company records show. So did Ariba Inc. co-founder Boris Putanec and Val Vaden, co-founder of financier Benchmark Capital.

Mr. Jermoluk, the former Excite@Home chairman, was both a founding financier of myCFO and a shelter customer. For fees of about $2.4 million, he acquired ostensible losses to offset as much as $50 million of taxable income, according to company documents and a deposition by his former accountant, Kevin McAuliffe.

Mr. Jermoluk declined to be interviewed about myCFO, as did Messrs. Doerr and Chambers. Messrs. Clark and Barksdale didn’t respond to email and phone requests for interviews. A lawyer for the former directors told a tax client last October that they “categorically denied…misconduct or malfeasance of any sort.” The lawyer, David York, predicted myCFO’s main tax package ultimately “will survive a substantive tax law analysis” in court.

A spokeswoman for Mr. Sonsini said his law firm did basic legal work for myCFO that didn’t include reviewing its tax offerings. Messrs. Vaden and Putanec declined to comment, while Occidental said Dr. Irani wouldn’t comment “on what is clearly a personal matter.”

MyCFO’s main tax shelter, sold to 17 clients, was called Cards, for Custom Adjustable Rate Debt Structure. Each involved an ostensible 30-year bank loan to a foreign party for $50 million to $100 million. MyCFO’s client then assumed the loan and, after some complex swapping of collateral, claimed a loss for tax purposes of nearly the full amount of the loan. Others besides myCFO also marketed Cards.

The IRS in March 2002 ruled Cards invalid. Largely as a result, myCFO sold its name and client list and liquidated its tax business.

The IRS said Cards failed a basic test of legitimacy: It lacked any real economic purpose other than to lower taxes. The agency added that clients were never really at risk for the supposed $50 million or more in loans.

Most myCFO shelter clients are challenging the IRS’s action, in federal court in San Jose. But two broke ranks and alleged the shelters were fraudulent, in civil racketeering suits they filed against big banks that underwrote their Cards deals. They claim they were misled to believe the shelter’s loan structure was actually a viable credit facility. (See adjoining article7.)

From the start, there were internal warnings. Mr. McAuliffe, a former Ernst & Young tax partner who was one of myCFO’s first hires, said that when the firm was just gearing up in 1999, some of its accountants wanted to shun tax “elimination” deals. He warned Mr. Jermoluk and Chief Executive Art Shaw that myCFO was relying too heavily on tax shelters for revenue, Mr. McAuliffe said in a 2005 deposition for a tax client’s lawsuit in San Francisco Superior Court. But he said the founders were talking about an initial public offering, and his warnings went unheeded amid IPO “fever.” Mr. Shaw, CEO of advertising firm Netblue Inc., didn’t return calls seeking comment.

MyCFO had obtained the Cards strategy from a San Francisco investment boutique called Chenery Associates, which also provided it to others. Chenery had done a Cards deal for an aircraft-leasing company, which registered it with the IRS as a tax shelter. The IRS requires corporations to register such tax-driven deals. Its rules for when individuals must register a deal they’re using as a shelter are less strict.

MyCFO officials said their clients would never accept a transaction they had to register as a tax shelter, Chenery Associates owner Roy Hahn later testified in a deposition for San Francisco Superior Court. A lawyer for Chenery removed the obstacle. He wrote an analysis saying that Cards wasn’t a tax shelter under relevant IRS rules.

The lawyer, Graham Taylor, then at LeBoeuf, Lamb, Greene & MacRae, wore multiple hats. He also represented myCFO in refining the tax strategy, court documents show. And when myCFO signed up Cards clients, it arranged for them to hire Mr. Taylor as their lawyer. For fees of roughly $85,000 per client, he supplied many of them with letters saying that if the IRS found their deductions invalid, they shouldn’t owe penalties because they had relied on “an opinion from reputable counsel.”

That counsel, it turned out, was a co-inventor of Cards, Raymond J. Ruble, then at law firm Brown & Wood. The law firm got $250,000 each time a client used Cards. Chenery paid this out of its share of the tax client’s fee.

Chenery also agreed to pay 20% of its own fee into a Ruble family trust, according to court records and Mr. Hahn’s testimony.

MyCFO directors had several briefings about tax shelters, minutes of board meetings show. One in mid-2000 led to a marketing delay while the firm’s general counsel reviewed the matter. Three months later, the IRS, in connection with a similar shelter, warned that “an artificial loss lacking economic substance is not allowable.” Within weeks, myCFO decided to go ahead with marketing Cards.

It quickly signed up 10 clients for fees totaling $16 million. As those deals were closing in late 2000, Mr. Ruble from Brown & Wood emailed myCFO an article in which a prominent tax analyst called Cards a blatant tax dodge. Mr. Ruble said the analyst had “totally missed the boat on business purpose,” which he said lay in financing opportunities.

As the tech bubble deflated, myCFO imposed layoffs and spending cuts, but not on the tax-strategies group. MyCFO’s growing reliance on tax shelters for revenue was discussed at a board meeting in August 2001. At that meeting, the board’s compensation committee, Messrs. Doerr and Clark, approved stock options for 94 employees — giving a third of them to the firm’s top two tax strategists.

One director asked if myCFO would have an obligation to refund clients’ fees if the tax deals were unwound. “It was basically, ‘Gosh, is this kosher?’ ” says someone who was there. “Then they read the attorneys’ comfort letters and everyone shut up.”

Mr. Doerr was a booster for the firm’s tax strategists. In response to Mr. Doerr’s 2001 email lauding the tax team for its performance — which he sent on Sept. 11, 31 minutes before the first plane struck the World Trade Center — the tax team’s leader reported landing $4.5 million more in fees. Five days after 9/11, Mr. Doerr replied: “This is AWESOME news, particularly during a week marred by national tragedy…. Please keep me posted.”

But some of myCFO’s accountants and client-service people were in revolt, according to Mr. McAuliffe’s deposition. In late 2001, he and several colleagues refused to sign shelter clients’ tax returns until myCFO agreed to indemnify them for any personal liability. One client was claiming a tax loss greater than his net worth. “It was only a matter of time until the IRS came down pretty hard,” Mr. McAuliffe testified.

In January 2002, the IRS offered a broad tax-shelter amnesty: It would waive penalties for any taxpayer who owned up to using a questionable shelter.

MyCFO staffers disagreed over what to tell clients about this and whether to discourage them from taking the amnesty. Ultimately, the firm sent out what General Counsel Steve Debenham, in an email about a draft to a colleague, called “a CYA letter,” for “cover your a — .” It said the IRS appeared to be focusing on the packages offered by major accounting firms, which “may be less credibly supported by a substantive economic justification….”

Mr. McAuliffe mocked that distinction in an email to colleagues. “Same law firms, similar or same promoters, same tax effect,” he said, wondering if myCFO was “smoking our own dope again?”

He also dismissed the idea that myCFO’s clients were penalty-proof for relying on reputable counsel. “You bought your opinion. You bought your comfort-level letter,” he said later in his deposition. Mr. Debenham and Mr. McAuliffe both declined to be interviewed.

Two months later, the IRS ruled that Cards was an improper shelter. MyCFO’s board discussed the ruling by phone. MyCFO by this time was little more than a tax-shelter brokerage, according to documents prepared for the meeting. If it closed its shelter business, it would forgo $10 million in revenue in the next three months and be in the red.

Instead of closing the tax business, myCFO tried to revive it by hiring a veteran of KPMG, an accounting firm that was especially active in selling tax shelters. The employee, Randall Bickham, brought a pipeline of tax deals worth a projected $7 million in fees.

The board also explored selling the company. MyCFO documents show Deutsche Bank AG, which had worked with myCFO on several Cards deals, expressed interest in acquiring the firm for $200 million to $300 million, but backed away, citing potential tax-shelter liability. Bank of Montreal agreed to buy myCFO for $90 million but it, too, backed out over the same concern, myCFO documents show. In October 2002 Bank of Montreal finally purchased just myCFO’s name, client list and some other assets. It paid $30 million, about a third of the sums the Kleiner Perkins founders and others had put in. Bank of Montreal now has a private-banking unit called Harris myCFO Inc., which declined to comment.

Directors assigned the rest of myCFO to a liquidator. They gave Mr. Bickham, the former KPMG man, a $1.4 million contract, paid in advance, to maintain files and assist clients in “controversy issues” with the IRS.

In 2005, Mr. Bickham was among those charged by the Manhattan U.S. attorney with tax evasion and conspiracy to defraud the IRS. The charges relate to work he did while at KPMG. He has pleaded not guilty and declined to comment.

Also charged was Mr. Ruble, the Cards co-inventor. He was cited for tax-shelter work he did for others, mostly KPMG. Mr. Ruble’s law firm had fired him, after discovering the deal he had with Chenery to funnel 20% of Chenery’s fees into a Ruble family trust.

By that time, Mr. Ruble was at Sidley Austin, which had absorbed Brown & Wood. Sidley Austin and KPMG both faced civil litigation over tax shelters, which they settled last year for $179 million, including legal fees.

Mr. Taylor — the lawyer who helped myCFO refine the shelters and assisted its shelter clients — was indicted in a tax-shelter matter in Utah. Both he and Mr. Ruble have pleaded not guilty, and both declined to comment.

Federal prosecutors also investigated a German bank that helped arrange some of myCFO’s tax shelters. In a deferred-prosecution deal reached last year, the bank, Bayerische Hypo-und Vereinsbank AG, or HVB, agreed to a $30 million penalty and admitted that the Cards deal contained “fraudulent and illegal elements.”

The bank’s confession didn’t mention myCFO. But it said “all parties involved” knew the Cards credit facility wasn’t a legitimate long-term loan and would be unwound in about a year to generate “the phony tax benefits sought.” Said HVB, in a Statement of Admitted Facts: “The transactions were prearranged by the promoters… and had no purpose other than generating tax benefits for the clients involved.”

Hyperlinks in this Article:
(1) http://online.wsj.com/article/SB117315094960127889.html
(2) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-mcauliffedepo-03062007.pdf
(3) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-final-McAuliffe-Exhibits.pdf
(4) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-doerremails-03062007.pdf
(5) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-hvbstatement-03062007.pdf
(6) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-boardpresentation-03062007.pdf
(7) http://online.wsj.com/article/SB117315094960127889.html
(8) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-deutschebank-03062007.pdf
(9) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-jonesruling03062007.pdf
(10) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-houlihanpresentation03062007.pdf
(11) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-bickham-03062007.pdf
(12) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-iranletter-final.pdf
(13) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-thurmonddepo-03062007.pdf
(14) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-case03062007.pdf
(15) http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/mycfo-businessplan03062007.pdf

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s